How the Arizona Tax Revolt will succeed where our elected officials have failed

It’s all about Grassroots activism. Together we are building the critical mass needed to change Arizona’s property tax system. All of us citizen patriots that are “Mad As Hell” at outrageous property tax increases and the flawed system that permits those increases can and will succeed!

Let me share with you this excellent article by Alan Keyes that explains how Grassroots and the Arizona Tax Revolt works:

"It's not about imposing things from the top down. It's really about building them up from the bottom." -- Alan Keyes
June 25, 1995
San Luis Obispo, CA

Any political strategy that depends on broad grassroots support for its success needs to be based on a sound understanding of how the grassroots works. Without such an understanding, the strategy will tend to miscalculate its approach to handling the grassroots, resulting in failure.

The fact is, the "grassroots" is not like anything else in politics. By its very nature, it’s fiercely resistant to central control--yet it can be incomparably loyal and self-sacrificing.

Properly understood and respected (as well as properly organized), it has the potential to alter an entire culture. Approached incorrectly, it will turn on those who seek to exploit it.

For these reasons, today’s major political movements tend to ignore the grassroots and focus almost exclusively on use of media to gather winning support at the polls. This works fine as long as the media are susceptible to being courted. But a cause that seriously challenges the media’s inherent or conventional tendencies cannot afford to rely alone on media exposure--including paid advertising. Positive gains by unconventional movements can easily be undone by the media through its powerful domination of the public mind. Freedom-minded Americans must therefore find ways to MOBILIZE THE GRASSROOTS if they are to have any hope of making enduring improvements to American society.

Definition

By definition, the grassroots is the bottom of the political pyramid, opposite the "establishment," which controls the top. While the establishment concentrates power in relatively few people in the highest echelons of power--typically party leaders, elected officials, appointed aides or bureaucrats, and others who wield considerable authority over others (and whose business is limiting others’ choices)--the grassroots includes virtually everyone else, those common people who do not necessarily hold any political office and who may even be getting their first taste of politics in a particular cause.

It is important to understand, however, that the above model is overly simplistic. The grassroots and the establishment can often be the same. People can function simultaneously in either realm, and many often do. In fact, a large proportion of grassroots activists are current office holders or party leaders who are deeply engaged, alongside common citizens, in what could only be described as grassroots activism--involving them in cooperative, advisory, or leadership roles with people of the lower echelons. At the same time, many at the grassroots are inseparable in the public mind from the highest levels of political power, because of their effectiveness in influencing elected officials to change public policy.

What this means is that, ultimately, "the grassroots" is an ATTITUDE. It is an attitude of freedom, of creativity, of unrestrained political enthusiasm, of willingness to band together with ordinary citizens for a common purpose. It has nothing inherently to do with holding a position. It is what some political leaders do outside or beyond their official duties when they get involved in popular causes. It is what regular people do politically alongside others of like minds, without undue concern for conventional roles or authority.

The grassroots is the very essence of politics. It is dumping tea in a harbor, or standing up and testifying at a local city council meeting, or taking a political candidate aside after a rally and giving him some advice, or handing out leaflets at a mall. It is that whole realm of politics beyond official station, although many of high station moonlight as grassroots activists--some unintentionally, by their willingness to rub shoulders with the citizenry.

Grassroots behavior

People at the grassroots are anxious to do something. They are especially anxious to do something MEANINGFUL--at least to them. They are politically-minded people who--when they find a cause worthy of their time, energy, and means--are willing to let go of inhibitions, fears, and preconceptions and jump into the cause with unusual passion.

Motivated grassroots activists can be counted on to carry the burden for any particular political cause. They will make phone calls, label envelopes, knock on doors, organize their friends and relatives, e-mail everybody on their lists, march in the streets, put up yard signs, attend rallies, volunteer for leadership, write letters to editors, lobby VIP’s, distribute petitions, donate money, and in countless other ways make great personal sacrifice for what they believe in.

They do these things because of their belief in the ideals that define what it means to be an American. Nearly all true grassroots activists in our nation--unlike establishment authorities who control the political process (including those in academia and the media)--are thus FUNDAMENTALLY CONSERVATIVE. They are at least believers in the sanctity of American’s founding ideals and are inclined to support the causes of economic liberty, natural law and justice, and moral responsibility. They are rock-solid, sincere Americans.

And there are literally millions who fit this description. Given the right conditions, they will perform yeoman work indispensable to the success of any major political movement.

Activating the grassroots

The real grassroots strength of America has never been fully tapped, at least not since our founding, when a large proportion of common citizens rose up and made a difference. Whatever grassroots activity we see today is restricted mainly to those individuals who are the most assertive or outspoken. Millions of others would join these visible activists--in every movement from pro-life to pro-marriage to pro-Second Amendment to pro-property rights--if they knew where to turn for adequate leadership, and if they understood how far America has steadily moved toward the brink of social and political collapse. Unfortunately, the grassroots remain largely dormant, due to the fact that even principled political leaders have never learned to fully inspire the grassroots to meaningful action and enlist their full help.

Again, it is important to stress that virtually all truly grassroots activists are sympathetic to moral conservatism. The lawless radicals we often see on the news holding America hostage are not genuine grassroots. They tend to be avant-garde elitists from academia whose main interest is dismantling America’s traditions, in preparation for a world of government-dictated servility.

They take their orders from above--not below. They are an extension of top-down plans for disrupting our society, not common Americans who sincerely want to preserve our nation from their position at the bottom of the political spectrum. True grassroots activism springs from ordinary citizens and tends toward principled American liberty, not dependency on increased government power.

That being the case--all those who would like to mobilize the grassroots for a particular purpose must, themselves, embody and follow ideals that are consistent with those of America’s founding, or the grassroots won’t rise to the occasion. This doesn’t mean simply rallying citizens to the cause of preserving our nation--although that is essential. It means respecting and exemplifying the very principles that rallied our forebears: treating the grassroots as equals; respecting the grassroots’ need for freedom; and recognizing that no one controls the grassroots from the top down.

Below are principles for working with the grassroots, based on the typical behavior of those who join grassroots movements. These principles cannot be divorced from any serious attempt to reclaim America through broad grassroots activism.

1. The most important thing to remember in dealing with the grassroots is that the grassroots can’t be "managed." You can enlist them, but you can’t centrally contain, restrain, or coerce them. Any attempt to manage, manipulate, govern, direct, exploit, or otherwise "use" the grassroots from the top down will fail, because such oversight is intrinsically antithetical--even offensive--to grassroots activism. Instead, those who seek to involve the grassroots in their cause must largely defer to the grassroots, even cater to the grassroots’ vision of the cause at issue. People at the grassroots can be led--within certain inviolable principles--but they can’t be made subservient.

2. The secret to enlisting the enthusiastic support of the grassroots is to inspire citizens with patriotic, common-sense rhetoric that defines a cause worthy of their wholehearted support. Most Americans respond positively to sincere appeals to preserving America’s distinctive ideals, and the more intelligent and sensible the appeal, the more effective. Any demagoguery or other calculated "motivational" techniques may rally some people for the short-term--but only the truth, spoken plainly and courageously without attempts at manipulation, will mobilize broad grassroots activity for the long haul. The goal is to persuade with reason, in a way that naturally evokes passionate support for the movement at hand.

3. Once inspired, grassroots activists want meaningful work to do. The role of organizers, therefore (besides inspiring the grassroots), is to give interested activists well-prepared resources that they can use to make their own unique contribution to the common cause. In fact, that is mainly all that enthusiastic activists need from those at the top of their movement.

With a variety of good resources from which to choose--including self-instructional handbooks, guidelines for potential activities, effective literature, quality signs, comprehensive contact information, up-to-date voter and party lists, and other useful resources--volunteers are ready to hit the streets in search of opportunities to make a difference.

4. Those at the top of the movement need to see THEMSELVES mainly as RESOURCES. Since they can’t do anything directly to "control" the movement, once it begins to attract strong activists, they will be most influential if they adopt a posture of doing all they can to help those below them. In fact, that is the essence of good leadership. Motivated grassroots followers will respond well to leaders who see themselves primarily as supports to those in the trenches. They will respond poorly to leaders who cross the line and try to use those in the trenches to further their own well-laid plans.

5. The grassroots absolutely must be trusted to take initiative. Because being "grassroots" is mainly an attitude that centers in wanting to preserve freedom, those who wish to mobilize the grassroots for a particular cause must respect and even nurture the attitude of freedom and creativity that is the very reason those at the grassroots are involved in the cause in the first place. Just as important, grassroots organizers must realize that there is more talent, wisdom, experience, and expertise concentrated at the grassroots than there is at the top of any political movement. Activists must be allowed--indeed, they must be ENCOURAGED--to take broad initiative and be creative in furthering the cause at issue. The results will exceed anything that detailed planning or micro-management by their leaders will ever produce.

6. Although grassroots workers need freedom in which to function, they absolutely also need guidance to help them know how to participate effectively with others in a cooperative effort. Few grassroots activists expect unrestrained freedom to do whatever they choose in a major political movement. Most prefer--and expect--sensible leadership from those at the top of the movement to guide them in working productively with others. A movement’s leaders therefore need to give grassroots volunteers clear written guidelines for working collectively. The only problem with doing so arises when official guidelines lack common sense or treat volunteers without due respect. All top-down policies in a political movement must be self-evidently reasonable, or workers at the grassroots will quickly lose interest.

Conclusion

These simple principles for organizing grassroots activists will--if followed at least in spirit--unleash the power of the grassroots to accomplish great things in the political arena, on a scale never before seen.

America wasn’t built by stifling the individuality of free-thinking idealists. Nor will it be saved by such means. Those who intend to renew American liberty and character need to lead the grassroots to cultural and political dominance on the grassroots’ own terms.

-

The Weaver Analysis
www.ArizonaTaxRevolt.ORG has completed a first review of the Weaver initiative filed on 11/5/07. It is impossible to be certain as to how the State Supreme Court will rule on any matter, let alone one that proposes to reduce state and local government revenue by perhaps 50%. That being said, the following are our findings:

Weaver's measure would likely be barred from the ballot due to pre-election (single amendment rule) challenges involving among other things repealing two different constitutional sections dealing with different subjects, (levies and valuations) and/or defining both valuation and tax caps. In the unlikely event it made it to the ballot and was approved by the voters, post election challenges would likely bar part if not all from implementation. It could potentially leave us without the levy limits that today are so effective in limiting the Primary taxing entities to a 2% plus growth tax cap.

California's Prop 13 had only one tax cap applicable to all property. The courts blessed this approach. Weaver has two different tax caps which may well constitute an equal protection violation and since all property tax is ultimately paid by us consumers, taxing everything other than residential at twice the rate is merely a hidden tax on homeowners.

One of the many down sides to Weaver's measure near and dear to the business community and all those employed in the construction or related industries is that it repeals the mechanism that permitted developers to petition for and establish improvement districts to fund infrastructure (paid for only by future residents of the development) another problem is that it precludes the ability of the taxpayer's to vote to increase taxes for any purpose including desirable programs like education, police protection and fire fighting. And perhaps the greatest problem is that Weaver claims to help senior citizens and those living on fixed incomes yet those seniors who had applied for the senior valuation option would have their full cash value frozen and would not have their value rolled back to 2003. The seniors would see a much lesser tax reduction than those not in the senior valuation program.

The courts will not look kindly on any plan that would preclude the public from increasing taxes. In short Weaver's plan would be too disruptive severely impacting both the public and private sectors and the very senior citizens she claims are the justification for her measure. The second largest employer after government, the real estate, mortgage banking, insurance, construction, development and related industries would be effectively shut down. What are Weaver's real motivations? Does Weaver understand the ramifications of her proposed changes? She should hire an Arizona Atty. specializing in such matters before asking volunteers to give eight months of their life to qualify an inferior product for the ballot.

Though it would be exhilarating to watch the various taxing entities in the state in a brawl for a bigger piece of the available tax pie it is likely that unless you live in Phoenix like Mrs. Weaver you would see fewer of your property tax dollars flowing back to your local community.

There is one organization http://www.ArizoanTaxRevolt.ORG that has a viable solution to benefit all existing and future Arizona property taxpayers. The Tax Revolt initiatives were carefully architected by a team of property tax experts and Attorneys who specialize in Property Taxation and Constitutional Law. The Tax Revolt measures avoid the many unforeseen circumstances and the draconian impact to necessary government services that the Weaver measure would cause.

Lynne, you were once a Tax Revolt volunteer. We have welcomed you back to assist the tax revolt and that offer stands, that is if you will scrap your proposal which would otherwise only serve to confuse the public and dilute necessary resources. Together we can win this thing that is if you are on the side of the overtaxed and not the overtaxers.